Product Design & Development
 Share
RSS Feed 

At Issue

I Drive A Toyota Yaris

 Permanent link

I want to yell “boom goes the dynamite,” but it seems terribly inappropriate. David Mantey, Editor, PD&D, drives a Yaris

By David Mantey, Editor, PD&D

I drive one, I don’t own one — the only vehicle with my name on the plates (2LGT2QT) is a ’98 Dodge Neon that has made me its most outspoken proponent since high school.

I remember the day a future cop and former friend rode beside me and called the Neon a disposable 10-year car. This weekend, I’m going to fly through Burlington’s one-way streets at 90 MPH, hoping he pulls me over. The obscene ticket will be worth my absurd gestures as he’s chasing me through the loop.

I’m not sure how I’ll pull it off. The Neon's transmission is shot and it tops out at 55 MPH, the brakes slip, and the power steering is hit or miss — and those only begin the to-do list that has me wishing I was motivated enough to cash in my clunker when the opportunity arose.

The door panels walked out on me years ago, and the trunk has an odor that reminds you of an episode of CSI — I assure you that it’s not a body, just a forgotten gym bag that went horribly awry in college and spent the better part of a summer under the La Crosse, WI heat. I will miss that hooded sweatshirt with my adolescent nickname embroidered onto the sleeve.

Back to the vehicle I navigated through the snow-covered streets of Madison this morning: a faithful, pedal-failure free Toyota Yaris yet to be recalled. It’s troubling to read news regarding the one thing you expect to be the safest on a day-to-day basis. Now, think of being the one to read it hot off the wire every morning as the car cools under an early February snowfall.

February 1, 2010 – AP – Madison, WI – If you drove in a Toyota today, you’re lucky to be alive …

The car is safe. The pedal does not stick, but every time my slush-covered foot slips off of the accelerator, I think I'm five minutes away from my fiery high-speed demise.

It’s hard to lambast a company on poor product design when it constructed the crumple zone protecting your feeble body. So I won’t. Toyota is the greatest car company in the world — as long as your life insurance premium isn’t due. Life insurance gags, they never get old. I apologize, I watched an episode of Scrubs last night, and this entire thing has been written with Zach Braff narration echoing through my malnourished brain. 

"This is unprecedented in having caused this huge problem for customers," said Shinichi Sasaki, quality control, Toyota. Yeah, life-crippling fear and death have been known to cause huge problems for customers.

Like I said, I don’t own the car. I own the aforementioned family punch line; but if I were to buy one today, you can bet that it would be a Toyota. Gas pedal flap aside, for my money, I haven’t driven a better car in terms of reliability, mileage and comfort.

My only qualm? The design staff put the cup holder directly in front of the heat fans. If you ever hope to enjoy a tasty winter beverage in the Yaris, make it one best served hot because that cup becomes hot enough to warm your child’s Chicken & Stars soup. I had an incident with pink lemonade. The reach, the burn, the spill, the pink-stained khakis, the family dinner, the hilarious brothers with a night full of ammo.    

The recall was late. The first patch was insufficient, and, if the comment sections have been an accurate indicator, people would sooner play roulette than pull out of the garage – then again, consumers do have a tendency to overreact when they’re inundated with body counts.

Let’s assume Toyota learned its lesson: The recalls are estimated to cost $900 million with $155 million lost in sales every week — I think the company's peering at the iceberg’s tip. We love good drama and harsh overreactions. I’m surprised that I haven’t received a Facebook invite to a mass Toyota burning in a field in rural Wisconsin.

Toyota has apologized, though it’s similar to a child telling his/her parent, “I didn’t mean it.” A postage stamp-sized piece of steel fixes the gas pedal problem. I have a feeling the public relations Band-Aid will need to be slightly larger.

Do you drive a Toyota? Do you fear for your safety? Do questions at the end of columns do anything for you? Comment below or send hate mail to david.mantey@advantagemedia.com. Also, I haven’t received a decent threat via the U.S. postal service in a while, so feel free to mail me a few sheets of loose-leaf as well, it’ll be nostalgic.


I am an engineer. I own a Toyota Camry Hybrid (Recalled). My children now are the owners of my used Tundra (Recalled) and Celica. My Tundra experienced the accelerator stuck in the mat phenomena. Fortunately I was able to move the mat and paid more attention to it from then on. My family and I have been loyal Toyota customers since 1992. I can say that as an engineer it still shocks me that from a systems design perspective in a situation where the brake and gas are applied simultaneously the gas wins and the vehicle accelerates uncontrollably. I understand mechanically that the brake pads wear down with continued application but to not have a safety sensor override seems ill-conceived. Does anyone know, is this design standard for all vehicles? I can’t try it a home because the answer is pre-determined. Just curious.
Posted by: L_Cubed at 2/2/2010 3:49 PM


I too drive a Yaris. Its a great little car and I regularly get 50MPG on runs from Boston to Buffalo.

This sticking gas pedal thing is blown WAAAY out of proportion. The probability of it happening is miniscule - I'm more likely to get hit by a truck. But even if it were to stick, its so easy to deal with compared to other, more likely mechanical mishaps like, say, a tire blowout or broken axle or unlatched hood flying open or a brake failure or ... If the gas pedal sticks, just step on the brake, shift into neutral, turn off the ignition. I'd probably do all three in a second or two. Of course there's still a chance I'll rear-end the guy in front I was following too closely anyway but I just don't feel threatened even if I was driving one of the recalled cars.
Posted by: HAL at 2/2/2010 6:51 PM


HAL hit the nail on the head, at least for an old school car:

"step on the brake, shift into neutral, turn off the ignition"

But this may get harder to do when you get into the realms of remote start, pupil and voice recognition etc. Your brain may know to say "car, turn off engine" but as the rear end of the big rig in front of you is approaching at ever increasing speed speed the voice recognition circuitry may have a hard time divining your precise intent from your mouth's exclamation of "OMG". Let's face it, design engineers who can't resist swapping brake and hood release, on successive versions of the same model. can't always be trusted to think things through.

But inside every cloud there is a silver lining and I, for one, will be using this opportunity to get a good deal on a "problem" Toyota. David?
Posted by: Pedal Power at 2/3/2010 1:09 AM


As vehicles become smarter operating systems, I think one reader had it right in applying Assimov’s laws of robotics. I refer to it as common sense, unfortunately, that seems to be neglected far too often.

HAL is right, it seems easy. Even with a pushbutton start, you shut off the car like an AWOL computer, you hold the ignition button in for three seconds before it kills – here’s to hoping you have three seconds to spare. I was surprised that with a car full of people, no one was the voice of reason.

As for the silver lining, I thought of using the opportunity to haggle a weary salesman down in price, but several readers wrote in suggesting a much larger, potentially company-wide electronics issue that will only be addressed when the company is forced to do more than issue patch kits. When I read “crippling tip of the iceberg” I figured that I could bide sometime to see it through. Could it be marketing overruling the engineering department?

It’s interesting to note that no change has occurred without serious speculation and forcing of hands.
Posted by: djamesmanny at 2/3/2010 10:22 AM


Step on the brake and shift into neutral, but be careful when shutting off the ignition. If you turn the key fully off the steering wheel will most likely lock and you will lose steering. It would be better to leave the engine racing and pull off to the side of the road and stop first then shut the car off. Engine damage due to over reving is preferable to an unsteerable car.
Posted by: Nebula at 2/8/2010 6:30 AM


David,

Test.. Test...

-Vipul
Posted by: Vipul at 3/2/2010 6:34 PM


register or log in to comment on this blog!

At Issue

Beta Products & The Human Guinea Pig
Mike Willshaw, Radius Creative
My Garbage Blanket
Anna Wells, Editor, IMPO
A Quick Fix
Meaghan Ziemba, Associate Editor, PD&D

Quick Links

Site Sponsors


Most Viewed

Videos & Webcasts

Cannon vs. Skull 3/17/2010
Schmit Prototypes builds a canon powerful enough to blow your brains out.   Continue
Dynamic Structures Digital Prototyping 3/17/2010
When designing their structures, Dynamic Structures uses Audtodesk Inventor to go beyond 3D design.   Continue
Augmenting Reality 3/17/2010
The new technology makes driving more safe and convenient by enhancing the driver’s site.   Continue